Now Reading: Soil Strategies: Coping With The Effects Of Cold, Wet Soils At Planting

Soil Strategies: Coping With The Effects Of Cold, Wet Soils At Planting

by Brad Colman, Director of Weather Strategy, and Ziru Liu, Senior Sensor Scientist, Climate LLC

April 15, 2019


Last year's wet fall and cold November were followed by a mild December, and then a polar vortex dominated the last part of winter, yielding overall below-normal air and soil temperatures across much of the Midwest. These wet, frigid conditions have resulted in substantial flooding in areas of the Corn Belt, which unfortunately means spring planting could be a washout for some farmers, and difficult for others. And for those who are able to plant, many will face obstacles caused by the colder and wetter than normal soils.

Major Flooding Impacts Midwest Farms

Record-breaking flooding has occurred across the lower Missouri River Basin, caused in part by a stormy March that brought heavy rainfall and melting snow to already saturated soils. The northern Plains is being affected by a heavy snowpack that is expected to continue to cause flooding issues throughout the spring. Specifically, parts of Nebraska, North and South Dakota, Iowa and Missouri are already experiencing devastating effects from these flood waters with some areas recording rainfall 500 percent above normal during March.

Map key indicates percent of precipitation above average. March precipitation was 150 to 500 percent above average across parts of the Midwest, including Nebraska, Kansas, Iowa, Minnesota and the Dakotas, resulting in major flooding in some areas.*

In all, an estimated one million acres of U.S. farmland have been flooded and will likely reduce corn, soybean and wheat production this year. Farmers in these affected areas are continuing to monitor conditions to determine if planting is a possibility and, if so, what it means for their planting and input strategies.

Cold, Wet Weather Soils Affect Planting Schedules

For the Midwest farmers who will be able to plant this season, unique challenges still remain. Many growers, unable to get into their fields, are now behind on their nitrogen and tillage plans as spring planting approaches.

“Farmers operate in a world of variables, but this planting season is shaping up to be one of a kind,” says Charlie Beeler, who grew up on a small family farm in central Iowa and is a field research manager for Climate LLC. “Monitoring field conditions and staying flexible with tillage, nitrogen and planting strategies is a necessity, especially with the harsh and unpredictable weather patterns we have experienced over the past few months.”

Beeler, who helps farmers make the most of their acres through field studies he conducts on Climate research farms near Fort Dodge, Iowa, says many of the farmers he works with are being pushed out of their comfort zones. “We’re in a bit of uncharted territory here – for many, it’s a time to explore new approaches and bring new tactics to the table. Staying alert and having the resources to quickly adapt to changing field conditions will be key.”

Climate Field Research Manager Charlie Beeler helps farmers enhance their operations through digital farming resources.

What are some of the reasons for these colder-and-wetter-than-normal soil conditions and what will it mean for farmers as planting draws closer?

The Cause: Low Air and Soil Temperatures, Record Precipitation

Following one of the wettest years in Midwestern history, including near-record fall saturation that delayed harvest for many growers and prevented some fall fertility and tillage plans, farmers have also faced a colder-than-normal winter across most of the Corn Belt. Some of the Midwest experienced well-below normal temperatures throughout February and into March. March began with extreme temperatures during the first week of meteorological spring, with most of the western Midwest 10 degrees Fahrenheit or more below normal, lower Michigan, Ohio and Kentucky six to 10 degrees below normal, and parts of western Iowa, southern Minnesota and northwestern Wisconsin more than 15 degrees below average.

Average air temperatures throughout February and in early March were well below normal across some of the Midwest.*

Major precipitation has been a factor as well. For example, this same period in March also included above-average precipitation with rainfall on March 10, breaking more than 150 daily precipitation records. Substantial precipitation was recorded throughout the U.S. during the month.

Record rainfall occurred across much of the Midwest on March 10, adding more moisture to already cold, wet fields and many areas of the U.S. experienced substantial rainfall throughout the month.*

Unfortunately for many farmers, the projected forecast is for below normal temperatures and continued wetter than normal conditions through April, May and June.

Colder and wetter than normal conditions are projected across parts of the Midwest for April through June. For the map on the top, the darker the blue, the greater the likelihood of colder-than-normal temperatures; for the map on the bottom, the darker the green, the greater the likelihood of wetter-than-normal conditions.*

The Effect: Cold, Wet, Fields

Not surprisingly, this Midwestern weather has also resulted in below-normal soil temperatures throughout much of the Corn Belt. For example, the first week of March saw average soil temperatures in central Iowa almost 10 degrees lower than the same time period last year, with Missouri and Illinois soil temperatures between five to 10 degrees cooler than the same timeframe in 2018.

In early March, soil temperatures registered five to 10 degrees Fahrenheit below normal across much of the Midwest.*


Soil temperatures were in 30- to 40-degree Fahrenheit range for parts of the Midwest during the first week of April.*

Cold, wet soil can affect field health and workability in a number of ways, including:

  • Frozen fields
    Lower-than-normal temperatures can lead to deeper freezing beneath the soil surface, and this cold soil also tends to dry out slowly since water has a higher heat capacity than soil mineral materials. In addition, we can expect to see a slower evaporation of water from the soil surface and a slower infiltration through the soil profile due to low temperatures. In short, fields will continue to be cold and wet, at least over the next few weeks.
  • Nitrogen, insect and disease implications
    Farmers who were able to practice fall fertility should monitor for the possibility of diminishing nitrogen levels caused by leaching, the loss of soluble minerals and inputs caused by heavy rainfall. However, these conditions can offer benefits to farmers are well. The cold soils can help to keep any fall-applied nitrogen from volatizing during the winter and help to reduce loss of anhydrous. In addition, the extreme cold may also help to reduce the survival rate of some insects and crop diseases during the following growing season.
  • Soil compaction
    Typically a freeze/thaw cycle of water can help to reduce compaction as ice crystals split apart the soil while warmer temperatures help to soften it. While this process has occurred in some areas, other parts of the Midwest have seen little evidence of this, and projected cool temperatures through the end of March may delay this process – and planting schedules. Farmers may also risk compaction issues if they bring heavy equipment into their fields before the ground is dry enough to work.

The Outlook

With indications that planting may be delayed, Beeler says that as challenging as it may seem, farmers should consider viewing all of the variables as an opportunity to explore new ideas and approaches – and digital farming can help.

He indicates that in his area, only about 10 percent of fall fertility plans were completed as compared to past years and addressing this issue could call for creativity such as “weed and feed” – mixing nitrogen with herbicide applications – and other techniques. “Some of these farmers may have to sidedress in the spring to make up for lack of fall anhydrous,” Beeler says. “But it’s a chance to run test strips and see how various nitrogen programs perform – weed and feed versus early sidedress for example – and the yield analysis feature in Climate FieldView™ can provide a clear understanding of the results.”

FieldView™ side-by-side maps allow you to compare critical data layers in your field, including application rates and more.

Most of all, Beeler says he is advising the farmers he works with to be as patient as possible while they wait for more favorable planting conditions. “It’s going to be a compressed spring and once it is dry enough to plant, things will have to move quickly.” Beeler says that FieldView rainfall reporting can help farmers stay up to date with field conditions to determine when they are workable.

“It will be an interesting planting season for most farmers across the Midwest and they are looking for every possible advantage,” says Beeler. “Digital tools can help them make informed decisions and play a key role in their success.”

*Maps courtesy of Midwestern Regional Climate Center.

About The Authors
Brad Colman directs weather strategy for Climate LLC and Bayer Crop Sciences and works closely with weather scientists at Climate LLC who develop and apply technologies to help farmers understand and plan for weather and field conditions. He holds a Sc.D. in atmospheric science from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

Ziru Liu is a senior sensor scientist at Climate LLC and works on high resolution soil and environmental characterizations with proximal and remote sensing technologies. He partners with Climate data scientists to derive insights from data layers to help farmers understand the variability in their fields. Ziru earned a Ph.D. in soil science from Washington State University.